Home » Talent » Currently Reading:

Deciding on how to decide who is talented

May 13, 2005 Graeme Codrington Talent No Comments

I met yesterday with a journalist doing a feature on talent management. Having spent over an hour talking about what TomorrowToday.biz does, I was unsatisfied with my answer to one of her questions. She asked, “How can you know if someone is talented or not?” My answer was that it would be difficult to give a definitive answer, since each job, company and industry would have a slightly different definition. I gave some suggestions though about a generic definition for talent: an inquisitive mind, a willingness to challenge, entrepreneurial flair and creativity, self motivated, self-honest (by which I mean they know their strengths and weaknesses as well as their personality traits), hard-working, technology-savvy, and so on.

So, I wondered to myself, they must be people out there who’ve tried to do this as well — come up with a generic definition of what we’re looking for when we say we looking for talented people. A quick Google found a few interesting sites:

  • Andy Brown Wants You! (FastCompany): As one of the most successful recruiters for the U.S. Marine Corps, Master Gunnery Sergeant Andy Brown is a master strategist in the battle for talent. Here’s how you can hire the few and the proud.
      Lazy man’s summary:

    • If you want to hire the best, have your best do the hiring
    • Use the interview process to look for those intangibles. We ask, “What motivates you? What do you want to accomplish in life?” A few people say, “I want a challenge. I want to join an elite team. I want to come out a better person.” That’s what we want to hear.
    • Create check points in the hiring process – stop it earlier not later.
  • How HR can manage talented employees? (PersonnelToday.com)
      Quick guide – short quotes:

    • Don’t be deceived. The ability of a single talented individual to have a disproportionate impact on organisational performance is the result of a fundamental structural shift in business. Driven by the combination of changes in technology, the economy and society itself, the demand for talent is here to stay.
    • Finding the people who can make a difference is particularly vital in these difficult economic times, when most organisations are concentrating on the key business issue of where to focus their most limited resources – time and attention – to create the largest impact.
    • Talent achieves superior performance: – Through urgent application of creativity – While demanding personal growth – With or without the support of the broader organisation.
    • Talent is urgent, which magnifies many of the ‘normal’ people issues as they come at you at speed.
    • Talent is creative, and this is psychologically linked to independent-mindedness.
    • Talent will know and want its own way, whether that fits in with the organisation or not.
    • They are reflective thinkers – giving time to considering their choices
    • They know themselves – particularly the unique strengths that differentiate them from others
    • They learn – especially from their mistakes
    • The consequence is that talented people are often ‘difficult people’.
  • The poorly travelled need not apply (The Telegraph): Globetrotting has become the norm as more firms seek managers with international experience.
      Quick guide:

    • cross-cultural experience is becoming the norm for ambitious managers
    • Kathryn Wainwright, director of talent management at Barclays, says: “Managers are increasingly asking us for international experience and we will find it harder to retain them if we don’t offer it.”
    • international business managers don’t have to be sitting down the corridor from their teams any more

    I still don’t think there is a generic definition of talent. But most people know it if they see it.

  • Related posts:

    1. Tesco, a talented company I’m always on the lookout for talented companies and I...
    2. How to motivate talented people in tough times – a story from Time Warner Harvard Business Press is releasing a well timed book called...
    3. Shouldn’t we all just pick another word? I’m referring to the word ‘talent’ when I ask this...
    4. 25 “talented” people behind the meltdown I’m currently researching and writing an article called “Talent has...

    Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

    Comment on this Article:







    Subscribe to this blog

    Subscribe

    Category Drop-Down

    Posts about Technology Trends

    How Gen Y sees the Gen gap

    March 20, 2010 Graeme Codrington

    How Gen Y sees the Gen gap

    The 11 March 2010 edition of the TIME magazine had a great cover article on “10 ideas for the next 10 years“. In the same edition, Nancy Gibbs (who has often written on generational issues for TIME), wrote an interesting short piece on how young people perceive the generation gap these days. It’s [...]

    Africa’s Gift to Silicon Valley: How to Track a Crisis

    March 17, 2010 Graeme Codrington

    Africa’s Gift to Silicon Valley: How to Track a Crisis

    A report under this title appeared in the New York Times on 12 March 2010. It’s a great example of a few things, but especially of the power of social media, and the fact that innovation (and competition) can come from anywhere these days.
    Read the story of how technology developed in the aftermath of [...]

    The future of money

    March 12, 2010 Dean van Leeuwen

    The future of money

    For years banks and credit card companies have held a strangle hold over the movement of money and charged exorbitant rates for doing so. Now this is changing and fast.
    Michale Ivey the founder of Twitpay has devised a system, using code that PayPal made available to him, that allows people to make payments [...]

    Twitter 10 Billion – quality not quantity

    March 5, 2010 Barrie Bramley

    Twitter 10 Billion – quality not quantity

    In the last few hours the 10 billionth tweet was tweeted on Twitter. As one would imagine there was all kinds of hype and excitement, as Tweeps with the necesary skills attempted to predict the time it would happen, and I imagine even be ‘the one’?
    My last tweet was 9999989724. Wild. Will be at 10 [...]

    Recent Comments

    • Graeme Codrington: From: http://philippschaefer.posterous.com/the-participa...
    • Graeme Codrington: Here is an example of how social media changes the power rel...
    • stace: lazy and sensationalist - I couldn't agree more...
    • Graeme Codrington: Here's another example - a company that developed software t...
    • Graeme Codrington: I agree with you on this point, Barrie. BUT... I just had a...

    Archives

    Tweet Blender

    workforcetrends: 41 Amazing #Pictures of Pollution in #China http://ow.ly/Diy9 (via @GWPStudio @Flipbooks) #Environment #green
    1 hour ago
    workforcetrends: Why Businesses Don’t Experiment ) - http://bit.ly/dDfita by @danariely in HBR (via @ariegoldshlager @gregkrauska)
    1 hour ago
    barriebramley: Getting married for the second time is the triumph of Hope over Experience' Charles Saatchi (via @kojobaffoe @Brendan_l)
    4 hours ago
    barriebramley: @702land what's @YoTwits? Headlines without links. Does anyone think this is useful? I find it anoying
    4 hours ago
    barriebramley: @MelanieMinnaar - Nice pause. Nice reply : )
    4 hours ago
    barriebramley: LMAO RT @_ShoN: I love U, I love U, I love U. Don't get me wrong, I love other letters also (via @LisaTroy)
    4 hours ago
    barriebramley: Family waiting lunch. Youngster playing game on mobile. Man on knees praying to Allah. Young woman hot pants swimming. Rustenburg. New SA :)
    6 hours ago
    barriebramley: @gregnietsky @brendan_l @clivesimpkins - why do people who say they 'grew up in the Church' never seem to see themselves as part of it?
    6 hours ago